Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo Cat Food

All cat owners would go through the process of choosing the right meal for their cats. It is the most important of all of your responsibilities as their owner. There would be a variety of brands available on the market, so it would be such a headache to identify which of those can be ideal and sufficient for your cats.

There could be a number of things you have to keep in mind and fully understand. If you are looking for great brands that are making a change in the pet industry, then it would not be hard to hear about Taste of Wild cat food and Blue Buffalo cat food. These companies are well known in the market especially in providing quality meals that could fit the preferences and needs of your cats.

This is the main reason you can find articles discussing Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo cat food. Both are performing greatly on the market and would offer everything you need. However, for a better understanding of your options and to provide the best meal that your cat needs, here are some things you should know.


Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo Cat Food Comparison Table

NameMain IngredientsProteinFatFiberPricing
Taste of the Wild: Canyon River – Trout & SalmonTrout, ocean fish meal, sweet potatoes, potatoes, pea protein, potato protein, canola oil32%16%3%Click Here
BLUE Indoor Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Menhaden Fish Meal (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Brown Rice, Barley, Peas32%15%6%Click Here
Taste of the Wild: Rocky Mountain – Venison and SalmonSalmon, fish broth, chicken broth, chicken liver, chicken, dried egg whites8%3%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Freedom Grain Free Chicken Recipe Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Peas, Tapioca Starch, Turkey Meal, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols)32%14%7%Click Here
Taste of the Wild Cat Food Variety PackSalmon, fish broth, chicken broth, chicken liver, chicken, dried egg whites8%3%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Pea Protein, Tapioca Starch, Menhaden Fish Meal (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols)40%18%4%Click Here
BLUE Healthy Gourmet Wet Cat FoodChicken, Chicken Broth, Chicken Liver, Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Natural Flavor, Cellulose8.5%4.5%1.5%Click Here

One of the two recipes being offered by the company comes with smoked salmon and real trout. It is the main ingredients used to provide high quality of proteins and other essential ingredients that your cat needs. It also comes with high level of amino acids to promote leaner and stronger muscles to your cats.

The meal comes with added minerals and vitamins to let your cat have added antioxidants, which are important and efficient for healthier and shinier skin coat. The meal is also highly digestible and can be safe for your cat’s stomach. It is guaranteed made with premium quality ingredients with no corns, grains, fillers, wheat, and any other preservatives or colors.

The company is family owned and use trusted ingredients from reliable sources all over the world. This recipe is created for finicky cats and for those that prefer to eat fish than other meats.


  • It helps to build leaner and stronger muscles to your cats.
  • It comes with added minerals and vitamins for complete nutrition.
  • It uses premium quality of salmon to ensure that you cat can get high level of proteins.
  • It is highly digestible thereby promoting healthier digestion.


  • You may need an extra source of fresh water to keep your cat hydrated.
  • There are cats that won’t eat this.

Are you in search for meals that is highly recommended for your adult cats? If yes, then this is the perfect choice for you! The formula offers the right quality of nutrients that your cat needs through various ingredients including brown rice and barley. It helps in maintaining the overall health of your cat while promoting growth and development at the same time.

The recipe is safe for your cats and there are no additives nor by-products added. Most veterinarians would recommend this to their customers guaranteeing you the overall benefits that it can offer to your cats. It is ideal for cats that have problems with their stomach as it is easily digestible and is very gentle on their stomach.

The dry cat food is offered in a variety of recipes and meals, so it would be easier for you to find one that best suits the condition and needs of your cat.


  • There’s a variety of recipes to choose from.
  • It is highly digestible and gentle on your cat’s stomach.
  • It comes with high protein sources for complete nutrients.
  • There are no fillers and additives.


  • There are cats that can be allergic to the grain content.
  • It is not recommended for older cats.

The second recipe that the company offers comes with venison and salmon. If you think that the first recipe is not suitable for your cat, then you can try this one. Just like the first one, it is also being offered in wet cat food variant that you can consider depending on the overall needs of your cats.

The Taste of the Wild: Rocky Mountain – Venison and Salmon comes with high levels of amino acids that are effective in building stronger and leaner muscles on your cats. The main ingredients are roasted venison and smoked salmon that are rich in protein and can offer the maximum nutrients that your cat needs.

It is highly digestible, safe, and gentle to the stomach of your cats. It can also help in promoting a healthier urinary tract for your cats. You can be assured that there are no grains, wheat, preservatives, and other ingredients added.


  • It comes with amino acids for leaner and stronger muscles.
  • It is gentle and tender for the stomach of your cat.
  • There are no preservatives, flavors, and colors added.
  • It comes with high level of protein for the complete nutrition your cats need.


  • There are cats that are reported to have developed crystals from this.
  • There are cats that don’t like the taste of this recipe.

Almost all the recipes and formulas from Blue Buffalo uses chicken as their main ingredient. It is no secret that cats love to eat chicken while they are in the wild since it can be a great source of protein. When choosing a meal from this company, you should also consider spending some time to look at the BLUE Freedom Grain Free Chicken Recipe Cat Food.

The BLUE Freedom Grain Free Chicken Recipe Cat Food is a premium meal that uses deboned chicken to offer the right levels of proteins that your cat needs. It makes use of different ingredients including chicken meat as well as turkey meat to create a delicious flavor that would be guaranteed to satisfy your cat’s palate.

This meal is recommended for cats that are trying to lose weight. Moreover, it uses limited ingredients making it easier to determine the main cause of allergies on your cats (if they have some) so you could know what to avoid later.


  • It is made with deboned chicken.
  • It has limited ingredients that are important for cats with allergies and sensitivities.
  • It makes use of all natural ingredients to provide complete nutrition to your cats.
  • It is efficient for cats that are obese and need to lose weight.


  • You need to make sure that you will train your cat to drink water for additional moisture.
  • It is not recommended for kittens and pregnant cats.

Do you know that Taste of the Wild offers only two varieties of recipe and formula? Yes, even though they have an established name on the market and is being considered by many consumers, they only offer two formulas namely: Canyon River Feline with Trout and Smoked Salmon, and Rocky Mountain Feline with Roasted Venison and Smoked Salmon.

If this is the first time that you would try out meals from said brand, then it is highly recommended to get the Taste of the Wild Cat Food Variety Pack. It is a variety pack that comes with the two recipes the company offers, so it would be more convenient to try both, so you could determine which variety suits you cats best.

It can be effective as it can help to save money than ordering the two products separately. This variety pack also features their wet canned version of the two recipes and comes with a good price that would surely fit your budget!


  • It is a variety pack that comes with two recipes from the brand.
  • It helps to save you money. It is a great deal for first-time buyers.
  • It helps you to easily know the preferred recipe of your cats.


  • It can be a waste if your cat doesn’t like it.
  • It only comes with the wet canned food variant of the recipes.

There are cats that are more comfortable for eating wet cat food because it is softer and gentler on their stomach. If you are interested in wet cat food, there is a long list of options available on the market and one of them is the BLUE Healthy Gourmet wet cat food. Even though this wet cat food is formulated for adult cats, it can also be used for cats of all ages.

It is a complete and well-balanced meal that is ideal and recommended for your cats and kittens. The formula comes with a flavorful taste and guarantees to provide the nutrition that your cats require. It is popular with many cat owners today and can be worthy of your money.

It is made with chicken as the main ingredient, just like the other meals from the company. It also comes with chicken liver for the additional nutrients that your cat needs. Due to the high level of proteins, it is highly recommended for both older cats and kittens that requires this kind of formula.


  • There would be no preservatives to worry about.
  • It makes use of chicken just like the other recipes from the company.
  • The moisture content is good for cats that have a sensitive stomach.
  • It is recommended for cats of all ages.


  • It can make your cat fat.
  • There are cats that would not touch it.

BLUE Wilderness is a sub-brand of BLUE Buffalo that focuses on offering animal meat as source of protein. One of their meals that you can check out is the BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult Food. This is a special formula that offers supreme benefits because of the high levels of protein added. It is safe and convenient for the needs of your cats.

This recipe boasts the “LifeSource Bits” claims on the company’s official website and is blended with other vitamins, minerals, and supplements for the promotion of your cats’ overall health. There are many cat owners that would prefer this meal especially if their cats that are suffering from the sensitive stomach.

There are no artificial flavors added making it safe for your cats. The main ingredient used is chicken and there are additional ingredients such as sweet potatoes that serves as the source of higher energy levels.



  • Cats may not like the taste of this.
  • It is not recommended for less active cats.

Taste of the Wild a Short Background and History

The main goal of the company is to offer meals that are grain free. Yes, they are best known to offer recipes and formulas that do not come with any grain that might possibly cause problems to your cats. The Taste of the Wild focuses on using higher meat protein to mirror the diet that our cat has while they are in the wild.

They want to ensure the quality of nutrients that our cats are getting thus avoiding the use of grains and other ingredients. Diamond Pet Food owns the company and had started operating since the year 1970. Despite providing high-quality meals to the consumers, they maintained a reasonable price on their products so that average consumers can still purchase and offer the meals to their beloved cats.

The company has a number of facilities that are being operated across Northern California. All of those facilities are implementing high standards procedures to ensure the safety and overall quality of the products before selling them out to the market.

Taste of the Wild Food Recalls

Taste of the Wild received numerous recalls in various situations. In the year 2012, they have received a class action settlement alongside with other brands such as Sold Gold Wolf King, Canidae, Kirkland, and others. Their main company, Diamond Pet Food had been dealing with different recalls over the years. Thankfully, there is only one that was associated with Taste of the Wild.

Diamond Pet Food Company received recalls about aflatoxins and salmonella contaminations on their products. This case was brought to the court and they have settled the issue together with the cases filed by many cat owners.

Blue Buffalo a Short Background and History

Over the years, Blue Buffalo has been serving many cat owners all over the world. They have started the company in the year 2002 and was known for providing high quality meals, not only for cats but for dogs as well. They are a family-owned company that assures to provide quality standard meals that they offer to your pets.

They make use of the freshest ingredients available that are locally sourced. However, they have various product lines on the market which can make it troublesome for first-time cat owners but, they offer different recipes and formulas depending on the specific needs of your cats.

You have to careful in choosing a meal that suits the condition of your cats best. They have several varieties that addresses cat owners’ different concerns like the BLUE line which focuses on the all-natural pet food, the Freedom line for recipes that do not come with grains, and the Wilderness line for formulas that focuses mainly on your cat’s need for their ideal protein source. There is also the Basics line that comes with limited ingredients for cats that suffer sensitivities and allergies.

Blue Buffalo Food Recalls

The company is very optimistic about the ingredients they are using in every recipe and formula. All of these are carefully created and developed by professional veterinarians, and ensure that your cat would not experience problems on this. However, just like the other companies, they have received several recalls for various reasons.

  • FDA issues a recall on their products for potential contamination of melamine. This mainly affects their dog foods.
  • In October 2010, they received another recall for high levels of Vitamin D. The same with their first recall, it only affects and involves their dog foods.
  • The most recent recall that the company received was last May 2016. The recall is about their dry dog food that came with mold contamination.

The Round Up

When looking for answers to the best cat meal, it would still depend on the condition and the needs of your cats. While both companies claim to offer quality meals that your cat needs, you still need to check if your cat would like to have a taste of it since some cats can be fussy eaters at times. Rest assured, you can sample a few products at first to see if your cats would like it or not. There could be a lot of people talking about Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo cat food, but your cats’ need will still decide what is best for them.

Rebecca Welters

Yes, I am that weird cat lady with 200 cats and live in the darkest corner of the city where no one dares to go! Joking! But I am a cat lover and have 2 Ragdoll cats called Toby, he's 3 years old and Dory, she's 8 years old. I'm 36 years old and live in the quiet town of Washington.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: