Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews

When you are looking for the best cat food brands, you’ll surely hear about Blue Buffalo. They are one of the leading cat food brands on the market. They are best known for having quality and nutritious cat recipes that are being offered for a decent and reasonable price.

They understand the need for high-quality cat dietary requirements and have formulated the best recipes to offer them. Blue Buffalo, just like any other pet food brand, offers a variety of wet and dry recipes for both dogs and cats.

They are a family-owned company that has been inspired by their own pets. According to the site, they treat their pets as family members and their office is set up to be a pet playground where there are pets on every corner.

There are many Blue Buffalo cat food reviews online that discuss the things that you can expect from the brand, and if you want to have a better background about their products, then make sure to read until the end. 


Blue Buffalo Cat Food Comparison Table

NameMain IngredientsProteinFatFiberPricing
BLUE for Cats Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Brown Rice, Barley, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Peas, Menhaden Fish Meal (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Oatmeal, Potatoes32%15%6%Click Here
BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Potato Starch, Fish Meal(source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Peas, Whole Potatoes, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Chicken Flavor40%18%4%Click Here
BLUE Freedom Grain Free Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Peas, Tapioca Starch, Turkey Meal, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Pea Fiber, Pea Protein, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 And 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Flavor32%14%7%Click Here
BLUE Healthy Gourmet Wet Cat FoodChicken, Chicken Broth, Chicken Liver, Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Natural Flavor, Cellulose, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids), Guar Gum, Potassium Chloride8.5%4.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Wilderness Tasty Toppers Wild Cuts High Protein Grain Free Wet Cat FoodChicken, Chicken Broth, Water, Chicken Liver, Dried Egg Product, Potato Starch, Natural Flavor, Guar Gum, Sodium Phosphate, Salt8%2.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Basics Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Wet Cat FoodFish, Fish Broth, Potatoes, Peas, Carrots, Sunflower Oil (source of Omega 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Flavor, Carrageenan, Cassia Gum, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids)8%2.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Basics Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Indoor Grain Free Duck & Potato Dry Cat FoodDeboned Duck, Duck Meal, Pea Protein, Tapioca Starch, Peas, Canola Oil (source of Omega 6 Fatty Acids), Pea Fiber, Natural Flavor, Potatoes, Fish Oil (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids)30%14%6%Click Here

Blue Buffalo BLUE Indoor Health Dry Cat Food is among the top-selling products of the brand that uses protein-rich and delicious deboned chicken as the main ingredient. This is formulated to offer a high level of protein that is important for the maintenance of your cats’ ideal body weight and condition. This also helps them have leaner and stronger muscles.

It comes with wholesome whole grains and vegetables that are responsible for providing a better quality of nutrients needed to support the overall wellness and health of your cats. There is no chicken by-product used and there are added essential vitamins, chelated minerals, and important antioxidants that support the immune system.

This is specially formulated to fit the needs of indoor cats that are less active and may need more energy. This also features the exclusive LifeSource Bits of the brand that is known to give and boost the whole-body system function of your cats. This is processed at a lower temperature than the other kibbles used in this recipe.


  • It is formulated for cats of all ages.
  • It offers a high level of protein for leaner and stronger muscles.
  • It is specially formulated for the needs of indoor cats.
  • It offers the exclusive LifeSource bits of the brand.


  • Some cats may not like this meal.
  • There are cats that may want a higher moisture level.

Just like the first recipe on our list, the BLUE Wilderness Nature’s Evolutionary Diet Dry Cat Food uses delicious deboned chicken as the main ingredient. This comes with a high level of protein that is important to support the leaner and stronger muscles of your cats, especially as they are growing up. This recipe features sweet potatoes that offer healthy complex carbohydrates and give your cats the right energy level that they deserve.

Aside from that, there are also blueberries, cranberries, and carrots that give antioxidants to your cat. This supports your cats’ immune system and helps them fight off different allergies or any other sensitivities. This is also formulated to have no artificial preservatives, wheat, corn, and soy as well.

It is free from grains and gluten, and there are no chicken by-product meals used. Mixing this gradually to the current meal of your cats is easy. To give you better assurance, the company made sure to include their exclusive LifeSource Bits in this meal. LifeSource Bits is the precise blend of the vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that your cats need for their proper growth and development.


  • It supports the stronger and leaner muscles of your cats.
  • It offers healthy complex carbohydrates.
  • It has added antioxidants for a healthier immune system.
  • It is free from grains and gluten.


  • There are cats that have allergies to fruits.

The BLUE Freedom Grain-Free Dry Cat Food is holistically formulated to help and support the needs of indoor cats. This is important because indoor cats may need more nutrients and carbohydrates to have enough energy in their playtime and other activities. This recipe offers carefully balanced calories that can maintain the ideal body weight of your cats.

This is a great recipe that is highly recommended for weight loss in or are having a hard time gaining weight. It uses protein-rich and delicious whitefish that can easily get the attention of your cats. It is formulated to be highly palatable and give your cats the right level of nutrition they need while maintaining their body weight and current condition.

This is formulated with no chicken or poultry by-product meals, no wheat, corn, soy, and any other artificial ingredients. It is safe and comes with a high level of protein to promote proper growth and development. This also offers LifeSource Bits that comes with an exclusive blend of minerals and vitamins for your cats.


  • The food supports the need of indoor cats
  • It is highly recommended for obese cats.
  • It is made with no chicken or poultry by-products.
  • It has the right levels of vitamins and minerals.


  • Some cats won’t like this flavor.
  • It is only formulated for indoor cats.

The Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Indoor Chicken Wet Cat Food makes use of delicious chicken that is rich in quality protein. This can help your cats have leaner and stronger muscles and maintain their ideal body weight. Some cats tend to be prone to different sensitivities such as obesity and others. This offers healthy garden vegetables and antioxidant-rich fruit for a well-balanced and complete diet.

There are no chicken by-products, artificial flavors, wheat, corn, or soy used which makes it ideal for the overall needs of your cat. It is safe and all-natural, so your cats can manage to prevent the occurrence of any kind of disease. It is available in a smooth pate texture that makes it easier for your cats to digest and get the nutrients that comes with it.

It has tender flakes of real chicken that is complemented by a savory gravy and flavors that your cat loves. This is available in variety packs that help you in offering other flavors to your cats like salmon and tuna.


  • It has a higher level of protein.
  • It promotes and maintains your cats’ ideal body weight.
  • There are no chicken by-products and artificial flavors.
  • It has a smooth pate texture.


  • Some cats won’t eat this meal.
  • Offering a variety pack can make your cat finicky.

If your cats are prone to allergies or have sensitivities, many veterinarians would have recommended for them to have a limited ingredient diet. This is important in order to easily identify the possible ingredient that is causing the allergies This recipe uses duck as the single animal protein source and it comes with other quality ingredients such as pea fiber and pumpkin.

The pea fiber and pumpkin is essential to support cats with sensitive stomachs and makes it easier for them to get the level of nutrients they need from the meal. This also offers omega 3 and 6 fatty acids that are ideal for promoting healthier skin and coat of the cats. It is a complete and well-balanced diet that can be perfect for the overall needs of your cats.

Also, it is formulated with no wheat, corn, dairy, soy or eggs. There are also no chicken by-product meals and it gives assurance to the cat owners on what their cats can have from it. This is also being offered in other flavors such as indoor fish and potato recipe, and indoor turkey and potato recipe.


  • It is a limited ingredient diet.
  • It uses duck as a single animal protein source.
  • It has pea fiber and pumpkin to support digestion.
  • It is free from additives and fillers.


  • Some cats don’t like pumpkin.
  • Most of the cats need more moisture content.

The Blue Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe is formulated to fit the needs and maintain an ideal body weight of the adult cats. This is a great recipe that features beef, bison, lamb, and venison as the main ingredients and it is highly recommended for cats that need a higher level of protein in their diet. This is ideal because it gives better nutrients that the cat needs to thrive.

It is also rich in fruits and vegetables that are offering antioxidants to help cats in easily fighting off sensitivities. This gives them the right protection they need and help cat owners to save money and time in having trips to vets. This is also formulated with no by-products, corn, wheat, soy and anything artificial.


  • It uses red meat ingredients.
  • It offers a high level of protein needed by your cats.
  • It is rich in antioxidants from fruits and vegetables.
  • It is free from by-products and harmful ingredients.


  • It is only for adult cats and not kittens.

Important Points to Consider

Blue Buffalo is one of the most popular pet food brands on the market that offers a wide range of flavors and recipes to choose from. However, with several other brands on the market that claim to offer the same quality of meals, you’ll surely wonder what’s the best choice for your cats and what can work for them. To help you answer your question, make sure to check the following points:

  • Affordable Price: Blue Buffalo has a lot of recipes that are formulated depending on the special needs of your cats, and all these are being offered at a very affordable price. This is one of the main reasons why most consumers consider the brand; to save money and still have assurance on the quality of the recipes that they will give to their cats.
  • Real Meat Recipes: All recipes of the brand come with real meat as the main ingredient. This is important as our cats are obligate carnivores and may need a higher level of protein on their diet. You can choose from a variety of recipes that use real meat ingredients depending on the preferred flavor of your cats.
  • Grain-Free Variant: If you want healthier options for your cats, the brand is also offering different recipes that are free from grains. This is ideal because most cats need higher levels of protein and fewer carbohydrates on their diet. It also helps your cats easily avoid sensitivities.
  • Cats of All Life Stages: When you check the description of their recipes, you’ll find that most of them are formulated to fit the needs of cats of all life stages. They have recipes that are good for kittens, adult, and senior cats. They also have a special diet that is formulated for each life stages. Make sure to know what works best for your cats beforehand.
  • LifeSource Bits: The brand is quite popular in offering their exclusive LifeSource Bits. This bit offers a precise blend of vitamins, minerals and different nutrients that are important in promoting the overall health and wellness of your cats. This is cooked in lower temperature to give the right level of nutrients that your cat requires.

Blue Buffalo History

The Blue Buffalo Company is still new on the market. They have just started to offer their products in 2002. This is a family-owned company and had experienced extreme expansion and growth for their business because of the quality of flavors and recipes they offer. Today, they are widely known on the market as one of the most popular pet food brands.

They have a headquarters in Wilton, Connecticut and makes sure that their products are manufactured in the United States. They have an expert team of nutritionist and veterinarians that are using US-sourced ingredients to formulate different recipes that are needed to promote the overall health and wellness of pet cats.

The company started offering single home-made dog food recipe and eventually expanded to what they are right now. They became a highly rated, all-natural pet food brand that is dedicated to offering the best quality of meal that is ideal for the needs of your cats. They use fresh and wholesome ingredients in their recipes and they have set a new standard in the pet food industry.

As the company grows, they have included four different product lines under them. This also includes all-natural pet foods and veterinary diets. The product lines include BLUE, Freedom, Grain-Free, Wilderness and Basics. Each of this line offers a different and special recipe that is formulated depending on the needs of your cats.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Recalls

Despite being considered as one of the best-selling cat food brands on the market, Blue Buffalo has been affected by numerous cat food recalls over the years. The brand is very transparent in sharing details about the sources of their ingredients and is known to follow the strictest standards in manufacturing their products. However, they have a long list of past recalls which includes the following:

  • In 2007, FDA had issued a recall for different products of Blue Buffalo because of the possible contamination of melamine on the recipes. This affected their cans of Blue Buffalo BLUE dog food, BLUE spa select cat food, BLUE dog treats, and Spa select kitten dry food.
  • 3 years after, the FDA had issued another recall for different dog food products of the brand because of possible higher levels of vitamin D. This affected a lot of their dog food recipes such as Wilderness Chicken Flavor, Basics Limited Ingredient Formula, Life Protection Formula, and others. There is no cat food recipe involved in this recall.
  • In November 2015, the company had issued a voluntary recall of their Club Size Wilderness Wild Chews Bones because of the possible contamination of salmonella.
  • The most recent recall of the company was in May 2016 where FDA had issued a recall on the Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula because of possible mold contamination.

Aside from those mentioned, there is no other cat food recalls from the brand and many cat owners still enjoy the quality, nutrients, and overall benefits that their formula offers to their pets.

The Round Up

The Blue Buffalo Company really is a truly great pet company which has admirable core values it upholds in the manufacture of its products.

Blue Buffalo is a sign of quality and all of the foods it produces are natural, protein-rich and nutritionally balanced foods which provide cats in all life stages with everything they need.

These seven blue buffalo cat food reviews reflect the very best products available throughout its entire range and product lines.

Rebecca Welters

Yes, I am that weird cat lady with 200 cats and live in the darkest corner of the city where no one dares to go! Joking! But I am a cat lover and have 2 Ragdoll cats called Toby, he's 3 years old and Dory, she's 8 years old. I'm 36 years old and live in the quiet town of Washington.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: