Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews

The Blue Buffalo Company is known around the world as one of the best pet food brands currently Operating in the market. The company began with a single homemade recipe for dog food and has since expanded into one of the world’s most highly rated and popular natural pet food brands.

The Blue Buffalo company is dedicated to producing only the highest quality pet food products which are made from fresh, natural and wholesome ingredients and formulate carefully thought-out recipes. Here, we are looking at the best Blue Buffalo cat food reviews.

The Blue Buffalo company aim to set a new standard in the healthy pet food industry and, although they began as a family-owned company, they have expanded and now have four different product lines. The four product lines include the Freedom Line (grain free recipes), the Wilderness Line (meat-rich formulas) the Basics Line (limited ingredient formulas) and the regular Blue Line of all-natural pet foods.

All four of these product lines offers kitty owners a huge variety of great flavour options in both dry and wet food.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Comparison Table

NameMain IngredientsProteinFatFiberPricing
BLUE for Cats Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Brown Rice, Barley, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Peas, Menhaden Fish Meal (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Oatmeal, Potatoes32%15%6%Click Here
BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Potato Starch, Fish Meal(source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids), Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Peas, Whole Potatoes, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Chicken Flavor40%18%4%Click Here
BLUE Freedom Grain Free Adult Dry Cat FoodDeboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Peas, Tapioca Starch, Turkey Meal, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Pea Fiber, Pea Protein, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 And 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Flavor32%14%7%Click Here
BLUE Healthy Gourmet Wet Cat FoodChicken, Chicken Broth, Chicken Liver, Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Natural Flavor, Cellulose, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids), Guar Gum, Potassium Chloride8.5%4.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Wilderness Tasty Toppers Wild Cuts High Protein Grain Free Wet Cat FoodChicken, Chicken Broth, Water, Chicken Liver, Dried Egg Product, Potato Starch, Natural Flavor, Guar Gum, Sodium Phosphate, Salt8%2.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Basics Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Wet Cat FoodFish, Fish Broth, Potatoes, Peas, Carrots, Sunflower Oil (source of Omega 6 Fatty Acids), Natural Flavor, Carrageenan, Cassia Gum, Flaxseed (source of Omega 3 and 6 Fatty Acids)8%2.5%1.5%Click Here
BLUE Basics Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Indoor Grain Free Duck & Potato Dry Cat FoodDeboned Duck, Duck Meal, Pea Protein, Tapioca Starch, Peas, Canola Oil (source of Omega 6 Fatty Acids), Pea Fiber, Natural Flavor, Potatoes, Fish Oil (source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids)30%14%6%Click Here

Hands down, this is one of the Blue Buffalo Company’s best products. This food is an amazing dry formula made with real chicken and grains like brown rice, barley and oatmeal to name a few. In addition to chicken and brown rice, there are seven other formulas and the bags come in a range of sizes, allowing you to experiment with smaller ones first.

In these dry food blends, there are no nasty additives or by-products, just good old fashioned real, US-sourced natural food for your kitty’s tummy! Some of these foods do contain fish oil though, so if your kitty has a sensitivity to fish then this isn’t the best choice. It is low on wheat too, which can be a major stomach churner for some cats.

Cats really do adore this food and they are always hanging around their bowls meowing for more, which is why it has earned its place at the top of this list.


  • Comes in an airtight ziplock bag.
  • The kibbles are very small.
  • Natural protein sources.


  • The food contains grains.

 This product is part of the BLUE Wilderness range – their most natural food range – and contains a hefty number of calories which come from quality protein and fat sources. Like most of the Blue Buffalo Company’s food, this formula ‘LifeSource Bits’ which are a blend of vitamins, minerals and antioxidants, which help promote digestive health.

The food contains no artificial preservatives, poultry by-products, corn, wheat or soy, and is a great alternative for a raw food diet, which some cats live off.

This is a chicken-based blend, meaning it is packed with protein and has sweet potatoes thrown on top, which provides a good source of healthy carbohydrates for your cat. This is a great food for outdoor cats but may not be the best food for indoor cats – especially lazy ones – as it does help them gain weight rather quickly.

This food’s natural formula and blend of proteins helps aid muscle growth and development, works to support a healthy immune system and enables quick and healthy weight, with calories carefully balanced between proteins and fat.


  • It is grain and gluten free.
  • Contains BLUE’s ‘LifeSource Bits’
  • Contains good carbohydrates.


  • Dry food can be troublesome for some cats.
  • The food is not organic, but ‘natural’.

The Blue Buffalo Company have truly made a great product here and have made a product which uses deboned chicken as its primary and most plentiful high-quality protein ingredient. Deboned chicken is considered as a super good source, and this formula also contains chicken meal and turkey meal as additional quality protein-based ingredients. The carbohydrates used in this food are primarily tapioca starch.

BLUE’s Freedom range is holistically formulated to support the needs of indoor cats. The Blue Buffalo Company carefully balance carbohydrates used in these formulas, helping your indoor cat maintain a healthy body weight. Also, this food does not contain any meat by-products or corn, wheat, soy or anything artificial either!


  • Contains a good protein source.
  • A good amount of protein for dry food.
  • No allergens or meat by-products.


  • A low amount of moisture.

This wet food is specially formulated for more mature cats, but it is great for any and all cats, indoor cats of all ages and stages of life and even kittens!

The primary ingredient of this chicken entrée formula is chicken, but its gourmet wet cat food comes in a whole range of flavours and formulas. Chicken is a common, wholesome and versatile protein source which is one of the most popular cat food ingredients by far.

Additionally, this food blend contains chicken liver, which is both a great source of natural protein and fat. The other top ingredients in this formula include brown rice which is a healthy carbohydrate.

The protein percentage count in this formula is quite high, and the low amount of carbohydrates makes this a great option for indoor cats who are looking a bit weighty; it will help them drop some pounds with regular controlled feeding. There is a very high amount of fat, however, which may not be suitable for your individual cat.


  • No feline allergens.
  • Relatively small amount of fillers.
  • Chicken is a safe bet for fussy cats.


  • An unusually high amount of fat.

BLUE Buffalo offers an awesome range of semi-moist or soft dry pouch foods which they call ‘food toppers.’ Whilst these are not foods technically in their own right, these make really great supplements to dry food or can be used as a treat. The Blue Buffalo Company’s range of toppers come in a whole range of different formulas, so you can find something for any cat.

All of these meaty products are made from chunks of tasty, wholesome, real meat which is soaked in a gravy and are made without any by-products, artificial additives or low-quality ingredients. BLUE’s food toppers are meant to be used as a supplementary food and cannot be fed as a dietary staple. Some cat owners do feed their kitties exclusively on these things, but we don’t recommend it; it’s not the most nutritionally balanced product.


  • No artificial additives, preservatives or colors.
  • Fresh, wholesome real meats. No by-products or fillers.
  • There are lots of varieties, enough to satisfy all kitty palates.


  • BLUE’s food toppers are supplementary and not a dietary staple.

BLUE Basics products are made with a limited number of ingredients to reduce the prevalence of food allergies, intolerances and sensitivities. Many of these foods are made with unique and interesting proteins which your cat probably has not been exposed to before, so this reduces the risk of an allergic reaction. This is why it is called BLUE Basics; it is the very basic level of cat food.

This individual formula has protein-rich whitefish as its primary ingredient, but there are other blends available Whitefish is a complete protein, so your cat gets all the amino acids and protein it needs from this single ingredient. It is well nutritionally balanced.

In addition to whitefish, this food contains some fish broth which is both a source of moisture and natural flavour – cats adore fish broth – followed by carrots and potatoes! These gluten and grain free carbohydrates add a tasty twist to this food and are easily digestible.  

BLUE Basics’ whitefish formula is jam packed full of very healthy fatty acids such as sunflower oil, flaxseed and fish oil.


  • Rich in nutrients and healthy fatty acids.
  • Whitefish is a complete protein.
  • Cats will love the flavour.


  • Contains carrots and potatoes, which some cats may not like.

This is a really great dry food option, which provides all the essential amino acids and important nutrients your kitty needs during its daily life.  BLUE’s dry food blend is a very unique, healthy and easily digestible formula, making it a great product to provide your kitty with the complete and balanced nutrients it needs, whilst using a limited number of ingredients.

As far as dry foods go, this is probably one of the very best on the market which will provide your cat with complete balanced nutrition. Many dry foods are low quality and are bulked up with fillers. Not this one, though, this contains only quality ingredients. If you’re going to feed your cat any dry food, feed it Blue Buffalo.


  • Cats consistently love BLUE formulas.
  • It is grain and gluten free.
  • It is a duck recipe, which cats tend to enjoy.


  • Dry food needs to be supplemented with wet food.

Out of all of the Blue Buffalo Company’s products across their many lines, we have hand picked and reviewed seven of our favourites and produced our list of the best Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews. This diverse list of products contains everything you could possibly ever need to satisfy your cat’s diet.

Blue Buffalo Ingredients and Allergens

The Blue Buffalo Company proudly states that their products contain many ingredients that are certified for human consumption. The ingredients of different Blue Buffalo formulas and product lines do differ greatly, largely depending on the specific product line.

For example, BLUE Wilderness dry cat food formulas are marketed as being a low in carbohydrates, high in protein line of products which is an alternative to raw feeding. Blue Buffalo also produces a hugely popular line of organic cat foods, which is under the product name BLUE Organic. This formula contains several ingredients that are certified organic, which is great if you are wanting your kitty to have a diet which best resembles its wild diet.

The Blue Buffalo Company also has a dedicated product line that includes a limited ingredient dry cat food formula. This line of products is designed to be fed to cats which have food sensitivities. The formulas in this line are under the BLUE Basics product name.

None of the Blue Buffalo Company’s formulas look to contain either corn or corn gluten meal, which is a common filler found in many commercial pet food brands. If your cat has a specific allergies or food sensitivities, you should always read the ingredients of any cat food formula.

Where is Blue Buffalo food made?

The Blue Buffalo Company has benefitted from rapid growth but, despite this, has remained a family-owned company with its headquarters in Connecticut.

Blue Buffalo states that all of their natural and high-quality food formulas are produced in the United States; they are carefully formulated by an expert team of veterinarians and nutritionists, using ingredients sourced from within the USA.

Blue Buffalo Food Recalls 2007-2010

It has not all been plain sailing for the Blue Buffalo Company, and Blue Buffalo did have to recall several of their formulas in in 2007 due to contamination with melamine.

These formulas were under the now redundant Blue Spa Select product Since the recall, Blue Buffalo has removed all of the ingredients in their formulas that were made and supplied by a company known as American Nutrition. This company added contaminated rice protein to their formulas, which was the trigger of the recall.

Again, in 2010, the Blue Buffalo Company also recalled several formulas due to the formulas possibly containing excessive levels of Vitamin D, but these formulas were all in the dry dog food product line and had nothing to do with their cat foods.

Sometimes accidents happen, and companies make mistakes. To make sure that the food you’re feeding your kitty is safe, you can check the FDA’s pet food recall website which can help you remain up to date with the latest information surrounding pet food recalls.

Pawsome Kitty’s Analysis

The Blue Buffalo Company works closely with industry-nutritionists and vets to create wholesome pet food formulas which contain blends of garden veggies, real meat, and good whole grains (none of that bulk adding stuff) for a varied diet which is properly balanced.

Only good stuff goes into Blue Buffalo’s food; all formulas use high quality animal meats as the first and most plentiful ingredient which is supplemented with healthy oils, healthy fats, fiber, and wholesome grains. None of the formulas contain any animal waste or meat by-products, corn, wheat, soy, or artificial additives.

The Blue Buffalo Company’s dry kibble formulas also contain Blue Buffalo’s super innovative and exclusive LifeSource bits which are contain lots of vitamins, nutrients and compressed nutrients which would be lost during the cooking process.

In addition to their holistic wet canned and dry kibble foods, the Blue Wilderness abd Blue Freedom product lines are also completely 100% grain-free. These limited ingredient formulas are a great choice if your kitty has an allergy or intolerance, or those who need high-protein, low-carbohydrate diets.

A Bit of Information

Blue Buffalo Cat Food is so very popular with cats and cat owners, and for good reason. First of all, cats really do love the great tastes of both the dry and wet versions of their foods.

When cats are switched to this food, they tend to exhibit more energy, thicker shinier coats, clear bright and moisturised eyes and less smelly cat poop. Cats with diabetes and weight problems do particularly well on a diet of Blue Buffalo Cat Food, because it is made of all-natural ingredients and is not crammed with rubbish.

Lots of cat owners have reported that their cats have lost a healthy amount of weight, and have maintained their ideal weights after switching to Blue Buffalo food. Other cat owners state that cats that previously had digestion and vomiting problems can eat this food without issue. Later on, our Blue Buffalo cat food reviews will help you decide on which product to buy, as we have curated a list of our seven favourite Blue Buffalo Company foods.

The Round Up

The Blue Buffalo Company really is a truly great pet company which has admirable core values it upholds in the manufacture of its products.

Blue Buffalo is a sign of quality and all of the foods it produces are natural, protein-rich and nutritionally balanced foods which provide cats in all life stages with everything they need.

These seven blue buffalo cat food reviews reflect the very best products available throughout its entire range and product lines.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply:

three × two =